Zohran Mamdani has ordered a sweeping review of how New York City agencies implement local sanctuary protections, appointing a former federal immigration official to oversee the process.
The mayor selected Bitta Mostofi, who previously held a senior role at U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, to audit six departments – including the New York City Police Department. The review will assess whether agencies are properly limiting cooperation with federal immigration authorities, particularly U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, as required under city law.
According to City Hall, the audits will examine internal procedures, data-sharing practices, and staff training to identify potential gaps in compliance. The administration says the goal is to ensure that sanctuary policies are consistently applied across departments that regularly interact with immigrant communities, such as law enforcement, corrections, and social services.
The move follows an executive action aimed at reinforcing privacy protections and strengthening oversight mechanisms within city agencies. Officials say the findings could result in updated protocols, clearer accountability standards and additional training later this year.
Supporters argue the review will help build trust between immigrant residents and local authorities, while critics have raised concerns about operational clarity and administrative burdens.
